@Nicholas - I am not a medical professional but suggest getting a 2nd opinion from a uro-oncologist. It is unfortunate that your urologist and oncologist do not have the same opinion as to what would be your best treatment. There may be a reason why your oncologist is on the fence and I might probe in to that reasoning. We find doctors who we trust and hope that they can provide us with guidance based on their experiences and training but that may not always be the case. Again, I personally suggest another opinion and possibly find out more specifics as to treatment - time for the treatments - weeks, months, possible side effects, what if the treatment does not work, etc. While RC is not a easy surgery, many of us have gotten through it and gone on to have a great life. I think that you need more information to determine the pros and cons of each option and which would be best and most effective in the long run. I wish you the very best. Please keep us updated and know that we are always here to support you and answer questions when possible. Linda Urbanski (moderator, Bladdercancer.net team member)